top of page
  • Nick Burgess

What Is A Safe Harbor 401(k) Plan?

The following article is for entertainment and educational purposes only, and should not be considered financial advice. Please contact a licensed financial advisor for individualized advice. Some links below may be affiliate links which generate a small commission for the site at no added cost to you.


What Is A Safe Harbor 401(k) Plan?

Picture the American small business owner: ambitious, tenacious, responsible for a legion of details from supply chains to customer service. They're also responsible for the welfare of their team, often offering retirement benefits to help secure their employees' futures. A retirement plan can be a complicated venture with numerous potential pitfalls, particularly in the area of nondiscrimination testing. Enter the solution: the Safe Harbor 401(k).

a man holding wooden blocks spelling out 401(k)

The Safe Harbor 401(k) is a retirement plan design, particularly appealing for small businesses. It employs specific safe harbor provisions, providing a form of insurance against complex annual nondiscrimination tests – tests that ensure the plan isn't disproportionately benefiting key employees over the non-highly compensated ones. If these tests aren't passed – the ADP test for employee deferrals, the ACP test for employer match and discretionary match, and the top-heavy test – the plan sponsor could face corrective distributions, excess contributions being returned, or the need for additional contributions.

Yet, the safe harbor plan design provides a free pass on these annual tests. With mandatory contributions, the plan sponsor secures the safe harbor status, sidestepping the need for testing. As a general rule, these contributions can come in two forms: a matching contribution or a nonelective contribution. A safe harbor match contribution typically involves the employer matching the employee's compensation in some way, up to a certain limit. Nonelective contributions, on the other hand, are made on behalf of all eligible employees, regardless of their own elective deferrals into the plan.

The Safe Harbor 401(k) isn’t merely a potential boon for the key employees. It could serve as a powerful tool for the entire workforce's retirement savings, especially given the immediate vesting schedule that often comes with such plans. The moment the plan sponsor makes a contribution, it belongs to the employee – no long waiting periods or complex vesting schedules.

This benefit to the employee isn’t a one-way street. The employer, too, stands to benefit. The SECURE Act of 2019 offered new tax credits for small business owners who start new plans with an automatic enrollment feature. This new safe harbor provision can provide specific tax advantages over a traditional plan, making the Safe Harbor 401(k) an even better choice for businesses considering setting up a retirement account.

However, Safe Harbor 401(k)s come with their own set of unique requirements. Plan sponsors must provide an annual notice to employees about the safe harbor features, the safe harbor notice requirements forming part of the larger plan document. In addition, safe harbor contributions must generally be made for the entire plan year. Mid-year changes are possible, but they come with stringent conditions and often require an advance notice.

These requirements also include deadlines that must be met. To implement a safe harbor option for a new or existing plan, for example, the plan amendment typically needs to be in place by the 30th day before the close of the plan year. For new plans, the safe harbor plan design must be operational for at least three months in the first year. As for nonelective safe harbor plans, under the SECURE Act, they can now be adopted up until the end of the plan year, or, with a top-up contribution, up to the close of the following plan year.

The details can seem overwhelming, but it's important to remember that the goal of a Safe Harbor 401(k) is simplicity. It's about making it easier for small businesses to provide a retirement plan for their employees without falling afoul of IRS testing requirements. A word to the wise, though, while this article serves to inform, it's intended for informational purposes only and not as specific financial advice.

The Safe Harbor 401(k) is a tool, and like all tools, it's powerful when used correctly. As an employer, understanding your obligations – from mandatory employer contributions to the use of cookies for your online privacy policy – helps you make an informed decision that can potentially transform your business and your employees' futures.

You have the power to give your team the gift of retirement savings without the dread of testing, excess contributions, or the excise tax. As small business owners, we juggle numerous balls, but with the Safe Harbor 401(k), at least one of those balls – the retirement plan – might just float a little lighter in the air.

By simplifying compliance testing and maximizing tax benefits, the Safe Harbor 401(k) is a beacon of hope amidst the sea of regulations and paperwork that is retirement planning. It can help ensure that your company's retirement plan is not just a benefit, but a secure and robust feature of your compensation package – and a key to a brighter financial future for all your employees.

The bottom line? The Safe Harbor 401(k) is no mere retirement account. For many small businesses, it's a life raft – a safe harbor in a turbulent sea.


bottom of page