top of page
  • Nick Burgess

Are Roth Contributions Pre-Tax, or After-Tax?

The following article is for educational and entertainment purposes only, and should not be considered financial advice. For individualized financial advice, please contact a licensed financial professional. Some links below may be affiliate links that generate a small commission for the site at no cost to you.


Are Roth Contributions Pre-Tax, or After-Tax?

Did you know that there's a retirement account (probably) available to you that is so powerful, there's a limit on how much money you can contribute to it? And this isn't some Baby Boomer, Silent Generation nonsense that came with their $50,000 house and free pension - this one has only been around since 1998 and, like that hooker you paid for, is waiting for you to take advantage.

a jar of spilled coins with a piece of paper streaming out with "ROTH IRA" written on it

The Roth IRA. It's an individual retirement account (IRA) that's got a lot of folks talking, and for good reason. The term "Roth" might make you think of something complex, like a math problem you'd rather not solve. But, fear not! It's actually a pretty simple, straightforward concept that’s a great way to safeguard your future earnings.

The Basics of a Roth IRA

Let's begin our journey with the basics. Unlike a traditional IRA, which uses pre-tax contributions, the Roth IRA is all about after-tax dollars. Think of it like a cake that you bake yourself. You purchase all the ingredients (your contributions) with after-tax money, your take-home pay, then let it bake over time. The best part? When it's time to enjoy the cake (i.e., retirement years), it's all yours—no further tax bill.

Is A Roth Pre-Tax?

Yes, you heard right! The key differences here between a Roth IRA and a traditional IRA revolve around when you pay your income taxes. With a Roth IRA, you're paying your taxes today, so you won't owe Uncle Sam a dime when you make qualified withdrawals. Conversely, with a traditional IRA, you make pretax contributions, reducing your current taxable income and getting an immediate tax break, but you'll pay income taxes later at your marginal tax rate on both the contributions and any investment earnings.

"Why is this good?" you might ask. Well, let's gaze into our financial crystal ball. If you think you'll be in a higher tax bracket when you retire (or that tax rates overall will go up), paying taxes now at your lower tax rate is a brilliant tax strategy. You're essentially locking in your current lower tax bracket for all your Roth savings.

Let's talk about some more potential benefits of this fantastic financial tool. With a Roth IRA, you don’t have to take required minimum distributions (RMDs) like you do with a traditional IRA. Your nest egg can continue to grow, tax-free, for as long as you like. In contrast, with a traditional IRA, you'll have to start withdrawing money once you reach a certain age (currently 72, thanks to the Secure Act).

Roth IRA Income Limits and the Backdoor Roth

Now, don't forget the income limits tied to Roth IRA contributions. They can be a bit tricky, especially for higher incomes. Single filers and those married filing jointly each have their own thresholds. If your modified adjusted gross income is above certain limits, your ability to contribute to a Roth IRA decreases, and may be eliminated altogether. If you're in that higher income boat, don't despair. There are still ways, like a backdoor Roth conversion, to get your after-tax money into a Roth account.

I want to emphasize that Roth IRAs are not just for the retirement-minded. They can also be a great tool for educational purposes. For example, you can take out contributions (but not earnings) at any time, tax-free and penalty-free, which can come in handy for paying for college. Always consult with a financial advisor or tax advisor for personalized investment advice before making these decisions, though.

When it comes to the question of Roth IRA vs. traditional IRA, or Roth deferrals in your employer-sponsored retirement plan versus pretax contributions, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It largely depends on your financial situation, your current and future tax rates, and what you're aiming for in your retirement years.

But imagine this: You’ve hit retirement, and you're receiving social security. You have a traditional account that’s subject to required minimum distributions, increasing your ordinary income. That increase may push you into a higher tax bracket, and it might also impact the taxability of your social security benefits. Having Roth savings that provide tax-free income in retirement can be a powerful tool for controlling your tax liability in these situations.

What Is A Roth 401(k)?

Don’t forget about the Roth 401(k) option. If your employer’s plan allows for it, making after-tax Roth contributions can offer similar tax advantages. The main difference? There are no income limits, and the annual contribution limit is higher than a Roth IRA. Plus, some employers even match a portion of your contribution. However, note that the employer match goes into a pre-tax account and will be taxable upon withdrawal. Always review your employer's plan rules to understand the key differences and potential benefits.

One final piece of advice: while it's absolutely beneficial to gather all the information you can, never underestimate the value of seeking professional guidance. Meeting with a financial consultant, financial planner, or investment advisor is always a good idea. They can help you figure out the best option for your unique financial situation, provide investment advice, and even assist in tax strategy planning.

Now, what if you've already made pre-tax savings into a traditional IRA or 401(k)? Roth conversions might be worth considering. It's a way to convert pre-tax dollars into after-tax Roth dollars. But beware, it comes with a tax bill in the year of conversion because you are moving money from a pre-tax account to an after-tax account.

Remember our cake metaphor? Here's a twist: You can't have your cake (the tax-free withdrawals in retirement) and eat it too (the tax deduction for your contribution in the calendar year you make it). Once you convert to Roth, you'll need to pay taxes on those converted funds, just as if it were ordinary income. It might be a hefty tax bill, but it can lead to tax-free income in the future.


Like any financial move, you’ll need to consider if it makes sense for you. Is paying the taxes now going to put you in a bind? Are you expecting a windfall (like from a new job) that will put you in a higher tax bracket? Then, a Roth conversion might be a good fit.

Whether you’re considering your first Roth contribution, your first conversion, or if you should go the after-tax basis route, remember: your retirement plan is not a one-and-done event. It needs regular check-ins, just like your health.

Always consult with a professional when it comes to your money. It's your future, your retirement, your peace of mind. And don't you want that to be as secure and tax-optimized as possible? I thought so.

Well, that’s it for today's post, my fellow finance adventurers. Remember, the world of Roth IRAs may seem mysterious, but with the right guide (be it an investment professional, financial planner, or your favorite personal finance blogger), it doesn't have to be. Stay savvy and keep exploring!


bottom of page